Skip to main content

Microbiology

Modified Acid-fast

This is a really useful variation of the standard acid-fast stain. The key difference lies in the decolorization step. We use a weaker decolorizer, which allows us to visualize organisms that are only partially acid-fast

Principle of Modified Acid-Fast Staining

  • Partially Acid-Fast Organisms: Some organisms, like Nocardia and Cryptosporidium, have mycolic acids in their cell walls, but not as much as Mycobacterium. This means they don’t retain the carbolfuchsin as strongly when exposed to a harsh decolorizer
  • Weaker Decolorizer: The modified acid-fast stain uses a milder decolorizer, typically a dilute solution of sulfuric acid (e.g., 1% H2SO4). This allows the carbolfuchsin to be retained by partially acid-fast organisms while still removing it from non-acid-fast organisms
  • Mechanism
    1. Primary Stain (Carbolfuchsin): Similar to the standard acid-fast stain, carbolfuchsin is applied to the smear. Heat (Ziehl-Neelsen) or a detergent (Kinyoun) helps the dye penetrate the cell wall
    2. Decolorization (Weak Acid Solution): This is where the modification comes in. A weaker acid solution, like 1% sulfuric acid, is used to decolorize. This removes the carbolfuchsin from non-acid-fast organisms and weakly acid-fast organisms, but allows partially acid-fast organisms to retain some of the stain
    3. Counterstain (Methylene Blue or Brilliant Green): A counterstain is applied to stain the decolorized cells. Methylene blue is commonly used, giving non-acid-fast organisms a blue color

Modified Acid-Fast Staining Procedures

The procedures are very similar to the standard acid-fast stains (Ziehl-Neelsen and Kinyoun), with the key difference being the decolorizer

Modified Ziehl-Neelsen (Hot Method)

  • Procedure
    1. Smear Preparation: Prepare a thin smear of the specimen on a clean slide and air dry
    2. Heat Fixation: Heat-fix the smear
    3. Carbolfuchsin: Flood the smear with carbolfuchsin stain
    4. Heating: Gently heat the slide from underneath for 5-10 minutes, keeping the stain steaming but not boiling
    5. Rinse: Allow the slide to cool, then rinse with water
    6. Decolorization: Decolorize with 1% sulfuric acid for 1-2 minutes, or until the runoff is clear. Rinse with water
    7. Counterstain: Counterstain with methylene blue for 1-2 minutes
    8. Rinse: Rinse with water and allow to air dry or blot dry
    9. Microscopy: Examine the slide under oil immersion (1000x magnification)

Modified Kinyoun (Cold Method)

  • Procedure
    1. Smear Preparation: Prepare a thin smear of the specimen on a clean slide and air dry
    2. Heat Fixation: Heat-fix the smear
    3. Kinyoun Carbolfuchsin: Flood the smear with Kinyoun carbolfuchsin stain
    4. Incubation: Allow the stain to sit for 5 minutes
    5. Rinse: Rinse with water
    6. Decolorization: Decolorize with 1% sulfuric acid for 1-2 minutes, or until the runoff is clear. Rinse with water
    7. Counterstain: Counterstain with methylene blue for 1-2 minutes
    8. Rinse: Rinse with water and allow to air dry or blot dry
    9. Microscopy: Examine the slide under oil immersion (1000x magnification)

Interpretation

  • Partially Acid-Fast Organisms: Appear red or pink against a blue background. They retain the carbolfuchsin stain, but not as intensely as strongly acid-fast organisms
  • Non-Acid-Fast Organisms: Appear blue. They have been decolorized and have taken up the methylene blue counterstain
  • Reporting
    • Report the presence or absence of modified acid-fast organisms
    • If present, describe the morphology and arrangement of the organisms
    • Example: “Modified acid-fast positive, branching filamentous organisms present (consistent with Nocardia).”
    • Example: “Modified acid-fast positive, small round to oval structures present (consistent with Cryptosporidium oocysts).”

Quality Control

  • Positive Control: Use a known positive control slide containing Nocardia or Cryptosporidium to ensure the staining procedure is working correctly
  • Negative Control: Use a known negative control slide (e.g., a smear of E. coli) to ensure proper decolorization

Common Problems and Troubleshooting

  • False-Positive Results
    • Overheating the slide during the Ziehl-Neelsen method
    • Using contaminated reagents
    • Thick smears
    • Insufficient decolorization
  • False-Negative Results
    • Over-decolorization
    • Using old or weak reagents
    • Too few organisms in the specimen
    • Not using the correct modified procedure when it’s indicated

Importance in the Clinical Lab

  • Diagnosis of Nocardiosis: Modified acid-fast staining is essential for detecting Nocardia in clinical specimens, such as sputum, wound aspirates, and tissue biopsies
  • Diagnosis of Cryptosporidiosis: Modified acid-fast staining is used to detect Cryptosporidium oocysts in stool specimens, which is important for diagnosing this parasitic infection, especially in immunocompromised patients
  • Distinguishing Acid-Fast Organisms: Helps to differentiate between strongly acid-fast organisms (like Mycobacterium) and partially acid-fast organisms

Tips for Success

  • Use fresh reagents: Old reagents can give unreliable results
  • Prepare thin smears: Thick smears can be difficult to decolorize properly
  • Control Slides: Use known positive and negative control organisms
  • Decolorization Timing: Pay close attention to the decolorization step. It’s crucial to decolorize just enough to remove the stain from non-acid-fast organisms but not so much that you remove it from the partially acid-fast organisms you’re trying to detect

Key Terms

  • Partially Acid-Fast: Organisms that have mycolic acids in their cell walls but not as much as strongly acid-fast organisms. They retain carbolfuchsin weakly when exposed to a mild decolorizer
  • Weak Decolorizer: A dilute solution of acid (e.g., 1% sulfuric acid) used in modified acid-fast staining to decolorize non-acid-fast organisms while allowing partially acid-fast organisms to retain some of the carbolfuchsin stain
  • Nocardia: A genus of bacteria that are partially acid-fast and can cause infections, especially in immunocompromised individuals
  • Cryptosporidium: A genus of parasitic protozoa that are partially acid-fast and can cause diarrheal illness, especially in immunocompromised individuals
  • Oocyst: The environmentally resistant, infective stage of Cryptosporidium
  • Modified Acid-Fast Stain: A variation of the acid-fast stain that uses a weaker decolorizer to detect partially acid-fast organisms